I am creating this list of church sales because my mom and I are big fans of going to them. They sometimes have useful things like clothes for really cheap and most churches will let you try on in the bathrooms before buying. I found brand new 100% peaches and cream cotton yarn skeins for $1 at St. Paul in Meno Falls rummage recently! This is a great price on that. I will try to remember to add my own comments to these after I go to them.
3/31/12
St. Joe’s Church
841 Martin St. Waukesha
8:00a.m.- 3:30p.m.
Bag sale starting at 2:30 – everything you can fit in a paper bag for ONLY 2.00!!!
Antiques! Tons of baby items! Men’s Wear Women’s Wear Kid’s Wear Furniture Jewelry House Wares Holiday Linens Books Sports Electronics Toys Maternity Shoes “Treasures” for all!
4/12/12 – 4/14/12 (Thursday, Friday, Saturday)
8-4 on Thurs/Fri
8-11 Saturday
Everything’s FREE!
Sponsored by St. Paul Catholic Parish
Hwy 83 & D, (S38W31602 Hwy D, located about 5.6 miles South of I-94 on Hwy 83 just before the intersection of County D), Genesee Depot, (Waukesha county), will be held in our Parish Life Center/lower level
Items include but by no means are limited to: clothing for women, men & children, shoes, toys, books, small house hold items, holiday decorations, purses. Just about anything seen at a rummage sale is here (NO large furniture), and all is FREE! There is no cost & items do not have to be brought in to take what is needed. Everyone is encouraged to bring your own bags to use. This is a great community service where donations are greatly appreciated to share with others!
4/16/12 (Saturday)
St. Boniface Annual Rummage & Bake Sale
W204 N11940 Goldendare Rd.
Germantown
This rummage had a lot of stuff at great prices. Hardcover books 25 cents, softcover books 2 for 25 cents, magazines 5 for 25 cents. I got a huge bag full of embroidery floss for 50 cents and a walker with a seat for $10 (these walkers are $60 and up in stores). Should come in handy when I am on vacation and my family wants to take a longer walk than I can handle otherwise. The Express News had a $1 off purchase coupon good til 12:30 with the info all on it. Bag sale starting 12:30. I do not see information on here how much the bag sale is. I will be going back to this one next year! This was a fairly large sale with books, magazines, movies, kitchen/household stuff, telephones, furniture and all was priced very cheap. They had a nice desk for $2 that I was tempted to buy.
4/21/12 (Saturday)
Divine Redeemer Church
31385 W. Hill Rd. Hartland
8am-2pm (12pm-2pm 50% off)
4/21/12 (Saturday)
CTS (Christ the Servant)
2016 Center Road, Waukesha
8:oo AM – 2:00 PM
Clothes, toys, furniture, household items, holiday decorations, sporting goods, books and more. proceeds benefit CTS’s youth group’s summer mission trip.
4/26/12 – 4/27/12 (Thursday & Friday )
Brookfield Congregational Church
16350 W. Gerbhardt Rd., Brookfield
9:00AM – 5:00 PM
household goods, furniture, electronic equipment, clothes, books, toys and more. Proceeds benefit church supported mission projects.
Thursday – Saturday, April 26 -28, 2012:
Thursday-Saturday September 20-22, 2012. Friday everything half off, saturday $5 bag sale.
St Williams Annual Spring Rummage Sale.
440 North Moreland Boulevard, Waukesha. Tons of treasures, clothes, furniture, jewelry, collectibles, dolls, tools, kitchen ware, small appliances,toys, glassware, baskets, antiques and more!
- Thursday April 26th 8 – 6. shoppers paradise
- Friday April 27th 8 – 6. Everything Half price
- Saturday April 28th 8 – 2. Fill a Bag for 5 dollars and take home treasures galore!Personal note: This St. Williams sale is one of the best sales in my opinion to get clothing. They usually have quite a bit to pick from, on Thursday morning anyway. This year clothing was 50 cents general, shoes $1, purses $3 unless marked but many were marked $1 or $2…coats and sweaters $3…can’t remember if jeans/pants were $2 or $3. Clothing for 50 cents is about as cheap as you can get I think and the $2 and $3 for other stuff is quite reasonable.
Dvd movies were $2 as were playstation 2 and xbox games also $2 each. Music cd’s were $1. I think this is really cheap prices on t hese things from what I’vee seen at other sales.
Hardcover books $1, paperback 50 cents, magazines 10 cents. I bought some cooking magazines and 2 church cookbooks. Prices on these are about consistent with what I seem to see other rummages.
Sheets were $3 for top sheet, $3 for bottom sheet, 50 cents each for pillow cases so $7 for a set. None of them were tied together like typically seen at rummage sales so some of the stuff was bought when we got there but not whole sets.
They also had several tv’s and cd players that all if not most of them worked. They had all the tv’s on at the sale so you could see they worked. They were various prices and models of those items.
5/10/12 – 5/13/12
8:00am-5:00pm
Eagle Business Association
This sounds like a community wide rummage of sorts. No specific address given.
5/18/12 – 5/19/12
8:00am – 4:00pm
Nativity Lutheran Church
6905 West Bluemound Rd. Wauwatosa
Saturday, May 12, 8:00 am to 3:00 pm
St. Matthias Episcopal Church in Downtown Waukesha
111 Main St. Waukesha, WI (Church entrance and parking lot on Pleasant Street.)
Held in our Fellowship Hall, so come to the sale no matter what the weather is.
Great stuff, great prices, friendly people. We have men’s, women’s and childrens clothing, fabric and craft supplies, books, toys, home decor and office items. Something for everyone!
saturday, May 12th
Rummage at Spring Creek church on Capitol Drive and Springdale intersection I am leaving to go to rummages myself today but this is a huge church so maybe some of you know where it is and can still go. 9am to ??
This was a huge sale, worth your time to go to. Lots of clothes, kitchen stuff, books (mostly Christian & kids ones), decorative items, electronics and more.
June 8-9, Friday & Saturday 2012
8am-3pm Friday
8 to 1pm Saturday Half price & bag sale day
W220 N6588 Town Line Road. Menomonee Falls, WI.
This is a wonderful sale. Church is 3 floors. Down in basement was holiday stuff and kids clothes. Middle floor I believe was adult clothes. Upstairs was several rooms of other type stuff including books/dvds room and kitchen stuff room. Elevators available.
June 8-9, Friday & Saturday 2012
8am-4pm
Willow Springs Mobile Home Park Park-Wide Annual Sale
This is located across the street from St. James Parish above.
Stretch Your Dollar Waukesha! 
I was just at St. Joe’s church’s rummage sale. I heard one of the ladies there say that this was the least amount of stuff that they had left. She thought that they sold more than usual. I think that you may have encouraged someone to come other than me.
I found me two new pants. I don’t need to buy anymore pants. I still need to get one himmed (bought at Target) but the used one’s are just my size if I wear shoes. Thanks for posting this.
I went to this also today and I did find a vacuum I needed, but didn’t think there was that much stuff I was interested in. We went first thing in the morning. But I am happy to get more people going to the sales too. Didn’t find many clothes in my size, they seemed to have mostly medium women’s clothes. I didn’t look super careful either, though.
i did like that they seemed to make an effort to be accesisble to handicapped. As in having a ramp to get in and having it on one level. I have trouble with stairs and it is a peeve of mine when places have a church sale on 2 levels of a building with no elevator.
great idea for this site. please keep us up to date. in case you didn’t know, st. mary’s is having a rummage sale at its festival this year (june 24-26) on hartwell. don’t know anything about it.
I realize it’s past, but St. Mary’s has a rummage sale every year, usually the weekend after Father’s Day. On the last day (Sunday), they have half price and fill-a-bag day. I got a bag full of stuff for $2 plus 17 canning jars for $1.50!